Men and women of a certain age, on finding themselves at a Christian service or funeral, will instantly recognise most of the hymns. They are the privilege who attended the Grammar Schools before Comprehensive Education replaced it around 1970, and sang these hymns daily at morning assembly. They know the tunes and words almost by heart. As the Grammar Schools were modelled on the English Public Schools, they were sung there too.
Many learned the hymns from an earlier age because, at least where I grew up, it was unicultural. It was Church of England or high Methodist. I knew of no Jews or other religions at school, and any Roman Catholic parents with strong views sent their children elsewhere.
Morning assembly consisted of a hymn, a prayer, and a bible reading usually by a pupil, followed by the Headmaster’s notices.
At the beginning of the First Year, we were presented with a copy of the school hymn book and bible, inscribed by the Headmaster with the date, your name and form number in Italic lettering. I still have my bible, but the obnoxious prat that sat in front of me in the Second Year, defaced mine by scribbling insults and obscenities on half the pages. The above is my dad’s copy. He went to the same school, but no longer had his, either. He bought this in a second hand book shop in the 1950s.
I loved those hymns. We sat in the school hall, boys one side, girls the other, and sang together. Of course, we messed about a bit. You could get away with a changed word here and there, such as ‘To be a Grim Pill’.
In the Senior Sixth Form, we sat above the body of the hall on the side balcony which on the boys’ side had the electric organ, a large and ancient beast of an instrument with pedals, the preserve of the crusty elderly music teacher. He had arrived in the 1930s as a dashing thirty something year old who the girls doted on when my aunt was at the school, but he was now regarded as a doddery old fool, no longer taken seriously. In music lessons, he had us singing ‘Who Is Sylvia’ and ‘Cargoes’, and writing out “memory tunes”, which did nothing to teach musical notation, and were meaningless squiggles to be endured. But, my, he was good on the organ. It sounded fantastic, and it was magic to watch him operate the pedals. I considered taking music at Ordinary Level, but was told no, you can’t take it with Chemistry; you have to choose one or the other.
What were the hymns? There were some great ones. As always, I was drawn to the music rather than the words, of which I often took little notice. I suppose those I remember most readily are those I liked best: ‘Eternal Father’ (For Those In Peril On The Sea), ‘Dear Lord and Father Of Mankind’, ‘The Lord Is My Shepherd’ (the Twenty Third Psalm), and ‘Jerusalem’ which we sang faster than usual and is better. We always sang ‘Lord Dismiss Us With Thy Blessing’ at the end of the school year. There are so many as the hymn book contents show. Also, the BBC ‘Songs of Praise’ programme ranked viewers’ favourites, which to me seems rather perverse in places.
To choose one, though, for me it would be John Bunyan’s ‘To Be A Pilgrim’ arrangement of Vaughn Williams’ Monksgate. Here it is as sung at Prince Phillip’s memorial service at Westminster Abbey in 2022. The Queen (she takes a while to appear) is clearly ailing and has only a few months of her own life remaining.



These hymns were part of our culture. It is sad that the majority of people probably don't know them. I practised playing 'Eternal Father' on the piano for my brother-in-law when he was coming home on leave. He was in the Royal Navy and the irony was lost on me.
ReplyDeleteMy exposure to traditional hymns was through Sunday School, church, and associated organizations. Our public school system in Canada was/is strictly secular, with limited exceptions. I still enjoy hearing some of those old hymns, although I've long discarded the belief system underlying them. Now it's just pure nostalgia.
ReplyDeleteI went to Catholic schools from 1st grade all the way through to college. I no longer believe in any religion, tho. We do still sing Christmas songs - religious and non-religious - at my home on Christmas evening. My sister will play the piano while we all sing along.
ReplyDeleteThe school system in Germany was very different from what you describe (and what I know from books and films), and when I started school in 1974, anti-authoritarians were very much en vogue. Hymns were for church, not for school, and as far as I know (not having children or grandchildren myself) it is still like that here. Of course during my school days, half of our class were children from Turkish, Greek, Spanish and Italian workers, and our class split up into various groups for Religious Education once or twice a week, so there was no common ground to be gained in that way.
ReplyDeleteOne of the most moving music moments I can remember happened while I attended a Sunday service at the United States Naval Academy Chapel in Annapolis, Maryland (back when midshipmen--all male then--were required to attend Sunday service). Hard not to be moved hearing a soaring 'Eternal Father' sung by more than 2,000 midshipmen--especially as it was during the Vietnam War era. Some of those young men eventually went on to face peril on the sea and did not return.
ReplyDeleteVery moving memories today. Prince Phillip's funeral seems so long ago. I am not sure why that would be. No one does pageantry like the English.
ReplyDeleteWell as a convent girl, the whole solemnity of the Catholic faith was absorbed but I just didn't believe from an early age. The hymn that frightened me was 'The Lord is my shepherd'. It is a funeral hymn, but my favourite was 'There was a green hill far away' but when I look at the lyrics I cannot understand why.
ReplyDeleteI do remember those hymns and readings during school assemblies. Whilst I enjoyed many of the songs the words never resonated with me. I still enjoy those songs and the Christmas carols at this time of year even if the subject matter isn't applicable to my beliefs.
ReplyDelete"To entrance the prophet's rear" is my favourite textual reworking. Childish, I know.
ReplyDeleteThough I have been a lifelong atheist, the hymns you referred to resonate deep in my bones. I love the way that "discouragement" is pronounced in the singing of "To Be A Pilgrim" which, if it isn't, ought to be the club song of Plymouth Argyle. By the way... who was Sylvia? Merry Christmas Tasker!
ReplyDeleteI did not grow up in church, however, I can imagine having a tie to these hymns sung in childhood would be very nice, indeed.
ReplyDeleteNo hymns in school assembly here so many of those so Gamiliar to those growing up in England were all a mystery to me when I moved there. References to Jerusalem went right over my head.
ReplyDeleteMicrosoft Copilot identified two melodies sung to Augustus Toplady's Rock of Ages. A DVD of Martyn Lloyd-Jones preaching to the unsaved, ends with the Doctor singing the lesser known melody with the choir. The words were written down when Toplady was sheltering from the rain in a Devon cave. I listen to the hymns of Charles Wesley. Also on YouTube I like The Old Rugged Cross and When I See the Blood -
ReplyDeletethe latter sung by Florence Wanabwa Ambayo. The blood signifies
Christ's death. We are saved by the death of Jesus on Calvary.
He took the punishment that we sinners deserve.
I must say "The Silver Swan" ranks right up there with "Who Is Sylvia?" and "Cargoes" in my book. I'm very familiar with "Eternal Father, Strong To Save" but have never ever before heard of "To Be A Pilgrim"...we colonials are so far behind the times at times.
ReplyDelete